Skip to content
The Advisory Alliance
All insights

Insights

Boutique or Global? How to Choose a Leadership Development Firm

Pick a global firm for reach and repetition. Pick a boutique when what matters most is who's in the room.

David HarperManaging Principal

A big hospital can treat a whole city. When it's your knee, you want to meet the surgeon.

The short answer: Choose a global firm when you need one program delivered the same way in many countries, or for thousands of participants on one platform. Choose a boutique, senior-expert firm when you're a large or mid-market company that needs a few leaders coached closely, and you want to meet the people who will do the work before you sign.

Neither choice is better in general. One of them is better for you.

I've seen this from both sides. Before I started The Advisory Alliance in Savannah in 2003, I worked and led teams of consultants with The Forum Corporation, then one of the big global names in leadership development. The work was with clients such as Merrill Lynch, GE, Bank of New York Mellon, and Unilever. Later, I served as Senior Vice President of Leadership Development with Partners International, a privately held management consulting firm in Manhattan.

Here's what I'd tell a CEO or CHRO trying to decide which type of firm to select:

When a global firm is the right call

Firms like Korn Ferry, DDI, and Heidrick & Struggles have earned their reputations. Start with them if:

  • You operate in many countries and need one program, in several languages, delivered the same way everywhere.
  • You're developing leaders by the thousands, with a platform and reporting to match.
  • You want one firm across the whole enterprise. At some, such as Korn Ferry and Heidrick & Struggles, that includes executive search as well as assessment and development.
  • Your board wants a household name on the proposal.

A good boutique firm will tell you when one of these applies. If it doesn't, that tells you something too.

When a boutique, senior-expert firm is the right call

  • You need a few leaders coached closely. A handful of senior executives, or one high-stakes role, is where the experience of the person doing the work matters most.
  • You want the truth. The higher you go, the later you hear the bad news. You want an adviser who has seen your situation many times before and will tell you the truth about it.

What mid-market companies need from a leadership development firm

A mid-market company rarely has a corporate university or a large learning or leadership development team. Many of its managers were promoted from technical or staff roles because they were good at the work, not necessarily because they were developed to lead. The company doesn't need an enterprise platform. It needs experienced advisors and coaches who will build the engagement around the company's real work, do the work themselves, and stay long enough to see whether behavior has changed.

Can a boutique compete with the big firms on quality?

In short, yes. In executive coaching and leadership programs, quality comes down to the person doing the work, not the size of the firm behind them. The large leadership consulting firms field excellent people too. So the question for any firm is the same: will the senior person in the pitch be the senior person in your sessions?

Scale is a different matter. A boutique can't run one program for thousands of people in thirty countries, and it shouldn't pretend it can.

Six questions to ask any firm, big or small

1. Who, by name, will do the work? Not who presents the proposal. Ask the firm you're considering who will coach your executives and run your sessions. Meet them, and put their names in the agreement. At a smaller firm, also ask what happens if the principal is unavailable, and who steps in.

2. How will we know it worked? Ask what gets measured before the work starts and what gets measured after. 360 feedback at the start and 360 feedback at the end tells you far more than a satisfaction survey on the last day. At the end of a recent 12-month coaching engagement, 360 feedback compared a leader with himself a year earlier. What a change. I then asked that same leader whether many of his colleagues had changed. "No, not really," he said. "They're just 12 months older."

3. What can we realistically get done with our budget and timeline? A good firm should tell you in the first conversation whether your budget can produce the result you want. If it can't, they should say so, and suggest what can.

4. Will you tell our senior people the truth? Ask for an example, client unnamed, of a time the firm told a senior leader something they didn't want to hear, and what happened next.

5. Have you done this for organizations like ours? Similar size, similar industry, similar problem. A list of well-known clients is a start. Ask about the work itself.

6. What happens when you leave? The best programs involve each participant's own manager and leave behind habits your people keep using. If the results depend on the consultant staying forever, that's a business model, not leadership development. A good consultant or coach, like a good parent, should become less necessary.

What does it cost, and what's realistic?

There's no single price for leadership development. Coaching one senior executive and running a program for forty managers are different projects. So compare the right things:

  • The total for the outcome, not a day rate. A cheaper day that takes twice as many days isn't cheaper. Make sure the company can give you a flat fee, not a day rate. You're not old-school hiring a taxi.
  • Who you're paying for. Who's doing the work? A senior adviser or a junior facilitator?
  • What's included. Assessment, 360 feedback, debriefs, surveys, stakeholder interviews, manager check-ins, follow-up, and a pre- and post-measurement should all be part of the engagement. Ask what's included.

Where The Advisory Alliance fits

Full disclosure: The Advisory Alliance is a boutique leadership development and executive coaching firm. Our promise is the one on our homepage: No fluff. No buzzwords. No jargon. No excuses. Here's how I'd answer a few of my own questions:

  • Who does the work? I direct every engagement and match it to the person with the most experience in your setting, from our network of more than 20 Executive Consultants.
  • How will you know it worked? Our executive coaching includes rigorous leadership assessments, inventories, surveys, stakeholder interviews, and uses pre- and post-program measurement to document leadership behavior change. Each leader's immediate manager and skip-level leaders are involved along the way.
  • Budget and time? Executive Coaching engagements typically run 6 to 18 months. Leadership Development programs typically run six to nine months.
  • What types of companies and organizations work with you? We design and deliver custom leadership programs and executive coaching for leaders at mid-market and Fortune 500 companies. Our client list is on our website: advisoryalliance.com/clients.

Frequently asked

Questions clients ask before they engage.

What type of firms are out there?

They fall into three main groups.

The large firms, such as Korn Ferry, DDI, and Heidrick & Struggles, offer similar reach; they typically deliver programs the same way in many countries, with little customization across individual leaders.

Coaching platforms pursue scale by connecting many employees of diverse and varying capabilities and backgrounds with coaches, mostly online and often through a standard process.

Boutique firms led by senior practitioners offer experienced advisers who build the work around your business and do it themselves.

Which best fits your company or organization depends on your size, your footprint, and the work. The Advisory Alliance, which I founded in Savannah in 2003, is in the third group.

How long does executive coaching take?

Usually 6 to 18 months, depending on the nature of the work to be done. Typical engagements should include rigorous leadership inventories, assessments, 360 feedback, surveys, stakeholder interviews, manager check-ins, and pre- and post-program measurement, so you can assess how the leader has changed.

Do leadership firms work with founders and owner-CEOs of established companies?

Many do, and the work is different. For the founder, the work is about growing the skillset the founder will need as the company grows and evolves, and their role becomes more complex. For owner-CEOs, the work can often be about succession and succession planning. Coaching the owner-CEO while developing the team beneath them is how a company becomes less dependent on one person, and a leadership transition becomes more successful.

About the author

David Harper is Managing Principal of The Advisory Alliance, the leadership development and executive coaching firm he founded in Savannah, Georgia, in 2003. He holds an MBA from Columbia University Graduate School of Business, is a SHRM-SCP certified member of the Society for Human Resource Management, and is a master global certification consultant for the Leadership Versatility Index®. He authors The Advisory Alliance's monthly 60-Second Read™.

More about David Harper

Ready to talk about leadership development for your team?